South America fights back in battle for its youngsters

March 4, 2008

Brazilian club Vasco da Gama have become the latest to complain about European sides trying to sign their best young players. Last week, Vasco president Eurico Miranda accused Real Madrid of approaching 15-year-old Philippe Coutinho. Madrid have yet to comment on the issue.

“Coutinho is only 15 and the FIFA rules are clear, transfers abroad are only allowed for 18-year-olds,” Miranda said. “They try to get around the law by taking those responsible for the player to live and work abroad. They offer a job to the father and take the player. But they’re not doing that here at Vasco.

“We have reported Real Madrid to FIFA and the CBF (Brazilian Football Confederation) for their approach.”

Will FIFA take action?
Last year, the president of Argentina’s River Plate said that soccer’s governing body needed to beef up the rules which prevent the international transfers of under-18 players.

“The policy as it is doesn’t go far enough, it should be much more severe,” said Jose Maria Aguilar. “The way it happens is a club from a Spanish city contracts a woman to cook and by coincidence she has a 14-year-old football genius son.” 
European clubs have been heard to argue that they are giving these players a chance to fully develop their talents in a way they would not be able to in their homeland. But that is hardly fair on the likes of River and Vasco, who are renowned for their youth policies.
Underneath the stands at River’s Monumental Stadium in northern Buenos Aires, the club has a primary and secondary school, gymnasiums and a dining area. The club even has a hotel where potential future players from the provinces can live while training.
Argentina and Brazil can hardly be said to have poor records when it comes to developing young players. But they simply do not have the economic clout of the European big boys.

Brian Homewood, Rio de Janeiro


We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see

Totally agree that the rules should become a lot sterner to prevent poaching like this from happening.
One of the reasons that South American clubs don’t have the financial acumen to compete with the likes of Madrid for control over THEIR players futures is down to the fact that European clubs come along and poach the best of their talent at a early age for next to no money.
If they were to be restricted purely to transfers abroad at the age of 18 then River Plate and Vasco Da Gama might stand a chance of earning some serious money for the football prodigies that they have nurtured.

Posted by Betting Blue Boy | Report as abusive

a boy, no matter how talented he is, must not be taken away from his parents under any circumstances. let them grow up in their native environment before moving to europe.

Posted by european football blog | Report as abusive

[…] South America trying to hold on to their youngsters [Reuters Soccer Blog] […]

Posted by Pitch Invasion » Links » It’s in the (inter)net! | March 8 | Report as abusive