Reuters Blogs

Reuters Soccer Blog

World Soccer views and news

12:01 April 18th, 2008

Who should Barcelona sign to replace Ronaldinho?

Posted by: Kevin Fylan
Tags: Reuters Soccer Blog, , , , ,

Kaka reactsThere’s speculation in Marca today that if AC Milan do complete a deal to sign Ronaldinho at the end of the season, they might be prepared to let Kaka move to Real Madrid.

That got me thinking about what the other knock-on effects might be, and especially about whether Barcelona would feel obliged to sign another big-name player as a replacement.

My own view is that this would be a good time for Barcelona to go down a different route. Ever since Joan Laporta took over as president they’ve pursued a relentless policy of buying in top names, from Ronaldinho to Deco, Samuel Eto’o and on to Thierry Henry.

For the first couple of seasons it worked very well, as the club regained their status as European heavyweights, won the league title and went on to claim the Champions League. Now, though, is surely the time to say enough is enough.

If Ronaldinho does go, the coach (whoever that might be) will still be able to call on Henry, Eto’o, Messi, Bojan and Giovani to fill the forward positions. And that’s the main difference between Barcelona now and Real Madrid when they were reaching the end of their ‘galactico’ era.

Real were so focused on their megastars that the squad as a whole had a threadbare look about it, which became increasingly obvious as time wore on. Barcelona have no such problems and if they manage to resist the temptation to throw money at another major forward it should just mean more space to grow for Bojan et al.

What do you reckon? Should Barcelona go out and sign a direct replacement — a Kaka, for example? Should they throw money at the Premier League to get a Torres or a Gerrard, Cesc Fabregas or even Cristiano Ronaldo (presumably untouchable, but you never know)? And while we’re at it, should Real Madrid pursue their interest in long-term target Kaka? Give us your ideas in the comments.

PHOTO: Kaka reacts during Milan’s Serie A game against AS Roma in Rome March 15, 2008. REUTERS/Chris Helgren

31 comments so far

I don’t think Ronaldinho is what MILAN needs right now. I rather have Ronaldinho staying with Barca. Milan needs younger and fit players. Young defense, that was Milan need right now.

http://italiansoccerseriea.com/2008/04/2 1/latest–italian-serie-a-transfers-news. aspx

- Posted by Anna Italia

nothing to do with Barca player,Barca play wonderful football and the whole world know about it .what ever team face Barca will play more defencive football .that why now it very dificult for Barca to score against them .I think Barca should change or improve more on the way they play .it is very hard n it need to have a litter of luck as well. Well done Barca .

- Posted by randy

i think barca should gt essien in he would give the powerhouse that the middle needs and id go and get silva and the valenica goal keeper they are going to have to sell after this year and no champions league next year.

- Posted by bernard molan

well i don’t think barca need any replacement for ronaldinoh cause they have alot of playmakers which they have not been featuring and so many talent on the bench which have not been taped and i believe if they consider all this the only thing they should be considering is signing a good and capable central defender

- Posted by loveday

after today its gotta be big john carew

- Posted by tokintony

Some in Italy are beginning to think it may have just been an election ploy by Berlusconi to say he was buying Ronaldinho. All the Milan fans voted for him and he is now prime minister again. He did a similar thing by claiming he’d sign Totti six years ago. He became PM but totti obviously stayed at Roma

- Posted by Mark

And an interesting call on Micah Richards, Paul. I know he received high praise earlier this season. How’s he been doing lately?

- Posted by Kevin Fylan

Still no sign of white smoke, by the way. http://football.uk.reuters.com/european/ news/L20206535.php
Probably just a matter of time, though.

- Posted by Kevin Fylan

Barcelona should sign Cristiano Ronaldo! lolz… Anyhow, i wouldn’t want to see Ronaldo on a Barca shirt. So i guess Barca should just stick with their young guns.

The only sad part of Barca is that Lionel Messi is always injured!

- Posted by goalcentre.com

i think ronaldinho isnt really replaceable but if messi keeps his form along with henry,eto ,deco ,xavi and bojan barca can do it….

but still if id say a player to go to barca for ronnie….id like to see pirlo exchanged for dinho (same superpasses..and free kick master as well! i can really imagine pirlo providing for messi and henry…ouch!! :)

- Posted by hamdy

Why not get in someone who is obviously an up and coming talent, without the ridiculously high price, and that has the potential to help the team in an area where they’re not strongest. To me the liking or Micah Richards, who still has alot to learn but is quickly becoming a very good player!

- Posted by paul

Post Your Comment

*
To prove you're a person (not a spam script), type the security word shown in the picture. Click on the picture to hear an audio file of the word.
Click to hear an audio file of the anti-spam word

House Rules:
  • We moderate all comments and will publish everything that advances the post directly or with relevant tangential information
  • We try not to publish comments that we think are offensive or appear to pass you off as another person, and we will be conservative if comments may be considered libelous information.