Germans incensed by another harsh penalty

June 19, 2008

Loew in training

UEFA’s decision to banish mild-mannered coach Joachim Loew from the touchline for Thursday’s quarter-final against Portugal is being put down to anti-German feeling by a lot of people here, a suspicion fanned by the angry response from German FA bosses.

It’s not the first time Germany have been hit with what neutral observers (I’d like to consider myself one of those) might view as a rather harsh penalty just before a critical match.

It recalled the suspension of Torsten Frings on the eve of the World Cup semi-final against Italy two years ago, for his relatively minor role in a post-match scuffle with
Argentina players. Germans also remember that they had to do without Michael Ballack for the World Cup final in 2002, although that was a more straightforward decision.

Is it a general dislike of Germans? Are there influential people that don’t want to see the country that has won three European Championships (1972, 1980 and 1996) and three World Cups (1954, 1974, 1990) succeed again?

Bierhoff was quick to dismiss such an idea at an eve-of-match press conference in Basel but he was annoyed in the extreme.

“These are isolated cases,” he said. “I don’t think there is a special story going on here. But in this case perhaps a fine would have been sufficient.”

Loew said after the incident that he had just been coming to the aid of Josef Hickersberger, who was also sent off, in urging the fourth official to allow the Austrian freedom to roam in the technical area at pitchside. Loew has no history of criticising referees and he quickly shook hands with Hickersberger as they walked together towards the stands. Loew’s arguments thus seem entirely plausible.

To stunned Germans, it feels like an innocent bystander got whacked around for trying to help. It seems like Loew first got arrested and has now been convicted for being a Good Samaritan.

Erik Kirschbaum, Berlin

PHOTO: Joachim Loew carries a goal during a training session in Tenero, June 17, 2008. REUTERS/Alex Grimm


We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see

[…] Source: Erik Kirschbaum […]

Posted by Soccer Camps » Blog Archive » Germans incensed by another harsh penalty | Report as abusive

this ban is absolute BS. I don’t care. They will still beat Portugal and win it all!

Posted by papa bear | Report as abusive

Sometimes it doesn’t pay to be nice. I am rooting for Germany in this tournament. Even as a neutral, after reading the arguments presented by Loew (and UEFA), he does not deserve this at all.

Posted by diana | Report as abusive

I really thought Loew acted very honourably. Fifa always talks about fair play, Loew should be given some fair play award!

Posted by Five Times | Report as abusive

Well Loew didn’t even need to be pitch-side today to orchestrate a tactical victory over Portugese counterpart Scolari – did he? The removal of Gomez from the eleven, the employment of Podolski in various parts of the field and the ensuing freedom for Schweinsteiger to work his magic – seemed to make all of the difference against a quality Portugese manager and team.

Posted by Beautifulgamer | Report as abusive

and that still didn’t work as germany kicked Portugal out of this tournament…yah

soccer playa

Posted by soccer playa | Report as abusive

I get the feeling UEFA actually did Germany a big favour by suspending Loew.

Posted by Erik Kirschbaum | Report as abusive

Yes, maybe they did. But it sure was unwanted by the UEFA and especially Michel Platini.

Posted by zoid | Report as abusive

Yes maybe they did, but it was sure unwanted by the uefa and especially Michel Platini.

Posted by zoid | Report as abusive

That wasn’t real fair. The fourth referee just lied – as the austrian trainer said and Jogi Loew just made his job the way all trainers should do. Fortunately that doesn’t has any negative effects for the germans. I think they’ll made it this time. Go Germany!

Posted by | Report as abusive