Do drastic punishments deter hooliganism?

September 22, 2008

Violence at the Red Star match

A Serbian soccer fan, tried for attempted murder after assaulting a plain-clothes police officer with a burning flare during a first division game last December, has been sentenced to 10 years in jail.

The verdict has triggered a nationwide debate among the country’s soccer fans over whether Uros Misic, a 20-year old Red Star Belgrade supporter, has been punished too severely or got exactly what he deserved.

Misic’s 20 or so companions in the courtroom threw verbal assaults at the judicial panel and had to be restrained by security while five of them were detained for questioning as the authorities showed a new level of determination to crack down on what the presiding judge called an epidemic.

Some believe the landmark case may be a turning point in Serbia’s desperate fight against soccer violence. Do draconian punishments deter hooligans from their senseless acts or could they make the problem even worse?

Misic’s Red Star comrades displayed banners of support for him in a league match the day after he was sentenced and chanted his name for the full 90 minutes. 

Serbia has been plagued by soccer-related violence in the past 15 years as a series of bloody conflicts tore the former Yugoslavia apart and resulted in what many analysts saw as a decay in moral and social values.

The first backlash was spiralling madness in stadiums, which the authorities appeared powerless to stop even after several fatalities where the culprits by and large got away unpunished.

A nation crippled by years of isolation and economic mismanagement seemed indifferent until the horrific scenes at Red Star’s ground, when Misic inflicted multiple burns on the policeman’s body before trying to force the flare down his throat.

At the trial, he based his defence on the assumption the victim was a rival fan. In the end, that may have made matters worse for Misic and prompted the judge to throw the book at him. 

Give us your thoughts.   

PHOTO: An injured plain clothes policeman (R) tries to arrest a man during an incident between Red Star Belgrade fans and police in Belgrade Dec. 2, 2007. A policeman was seriously injured when Red Star fans clashed with police during the Serbian first division soccer match against Red Star-Hajduk. REUTERS/Stringer


We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see

10 years in jail for that young boy ? it`s a good sentence,they should make some law for the hooligan, so they will think before make some stupid action.

Posted by cilvint | Report as abusive

The authorities have been cracking down hard on the hooligan problem here in Italy and it seems to be working. Fans are banned from travelling to away matches even if there is the slightest risk of trouble.
Teams are fined for fans having flares and crackers/bangers and it has made a difference. Looking at Red Star games, it is mainly the flares that give off that air of aggression. 10 years seems appropriate if he tried to force it down the guy’s throat.

Posted by Mark Meadows | Report as abusive