So what now for Tottenham?

October 27, 2008

A seismic weekend at Tottenham resulted in the ruthless cull of Juande Ramos and his coaching team and the sacking of director of football Damien Comolli.

Harry Redknapp was then hired as the club’s new manager just hours before the north London club claimed a first league victory of the season against Bolton.

However, their league position is still precarious (they are bottom, a point worse off than Newcastle) and there are many Spurs fans who are uncomfortable with the appointment

Not just because Redknapp has strong connections with West Ham United, but because his main attribute appears to be guiding average sides away from relegation.

Apart from last year’s FA Cup victory with Portsmouth, the 61-year-old Redknapp’s CV highlights are none too impressive.

Sure, he saved Portsmouth from relegation a few years ago and will probably have enough tricks up his sleeve to get Tottenham into mid-table by the end of the season.

But, what then? Is Redknapp really the man that can make Tottenham a force again? Can anybody?

It is a stark admission of failure by chairman Daniel Levy that he has gone back to basics after several unsuccessful attempts to discover Tottenham’s own “Arsene Wenger”.

Since Wenger took charge of Arsenal in 1996, Spurs have entrusted Swiss Christian Gross, Frenchman Jacques Santini, Dutchman Martin Jol and Spaniard Juande Ramos with trying to close the gap on their north London rivals.

Quite frankly, apart from Jol who turned Tottenham into a serious league force and came within 90 minutes of taking the club into the Champions League, the flirtations with European coaches have been a disaster.

The appointment of Redknapp also spells the end of Levy’s preference for a European-style management structure. There will be no director of football and Redknapp has made it clear that only players he wants will be in the squad.

What many fans cannot understand is why Jol, who guided Spurs to consecutive fifth-placed finishes, was not allowed the same responsibility.

Instead, he was undermined by Comolli and eventually sacked — a decision that now appears to have put the club back years.

Tottenham play Arsenal at the Emirates on Wednesday and thousands of Spurs fans, whether they admit it or not, will be looking on with envy and asking the nagging question, “What if Wenger had chosen the other half of north London?”

Redknapp may provide some instant comfort but sadly, Tottenham fans seem destined for many more years of pain.

PHOTO:  New Spurs boss Redknapp comes out of the tunnel ahead of his side’s game against Bolton Wanderers. Oct.26 REUTERS/Kieran Doherty

2 comments

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/

[...] the­ir le­ag­ue­ p­o­s­itio­n is­ s­till [...] Go­ t­o­ So­ur­ce­ Last 5 posts in Premier LeagueMourinho to Manchester United is actually not so mad – October 27th, [...]

Poor old Spurs fans. I agree with Martyn. Whilst Redknapp seems a great guy most fans will agree that Harry’s wheeling and dealing will only get them half way up the Premier League table at best.

That is the environment that he is used to and performs well in… so Spurs can’t be expecting much more of him than mid-table safety.

In saying that, one-step at a time. Spurs are in desperate need of a steady hand right now and if Harry’s tenure can provide stability, a hard-working team and a more consistent playing style to pass onto a different manager in a year or two, then this appointment wouldn’t be so bad after all.

Posted by Neil | Report as abusive

A rather negative article which doesn’t reflect the majority of spurs fans opinion. The situation with Ramos could not have continued any further, especially if reports of the senior squad members coming forward with their own doubts are true. Harry is english and is probably more experienced than anyone within the english game to take this club on to great things. What is the point at looking at the negatives here? This is a positive change and possibly the only one Levy had to make, regardless of connections with West Ham or not. Who cares?

Posted by Stuart Johnson | Report as abusive

[...] Redknapp may not have achieved anything at the level of what the Tottenham Hotspur board and supporters demand, but he will at least [...]

[...] to Source Share and [...]