Reuters Soccer Blog

World Soccer views and news

UPDATE – The painful art of score prediction — round 10

October 26, 2009

So it was an even worse week than usual. Ok, there were some surprise results but generally it was pitiful, some panelists only picked up one point and even most of our outside contributors struggled despite showing us up in recent weeks.

On behalf of all of us, I’d like to point out that the Premier League is more evenly balanced than it has been for a while (see Kevin’s blog) so we have a slight excuse….

Mitch Phillips was the only one to come out of the weekend with any credit, leaping into second spot after getting two scores bang on including West Ham 2-2 Arsenal, which sadly for the rest of us was a double-pointer.

To avoid a plethora of emails from Mitch and to keep it tight at the top, we will let his prediction of a draw in Wolves v Villa stand despite him sending in his entry after the match had started!

Here are the updated scores:

Reuters Soccer Blog panel: Patrick Johnston 92, Mitch Phillips 81, Paul Radford 79, Simon Evans 71, Mike Collett 70, Kevin Fylan 66, Miles Evans 63, Julien Pretot 59, Mark Meadows 50, Asia Sports Desk 48, Neil Maidment 44, Justin Palmer 36, Martyn Herman 10, Soxley (newbie) 2

Mark Meadows

———————————————————————————
Kevin’s post from Oct 23:
Can you hear that? A trouserly whoosh through the air, a dull thud and a sharp shriek?

Yes, it’s the sound of Reuters Soccer Blog panellists kicking themselves at their latest failed attempts to demonstrate they actually know something about the game they report on.

With a couple of honourable exceptions (step forward Mr. Michael Collett with 19 points last weekend) it was another case of the blind leading the blind here at Canary Wharf.

Remindingly, you get five points if you get a score prediction spot on, or one point if you get the right result but the wrong score. That means there are at least 50 points at stake, always bearing in mind that if you can predict scores that well you should be making money off the bookmakers, not frittering away your time here.

Here are the scores as they stand:

Reuters Soccer Blog panel: Patrick Johnston 89, Paul Radford 77, Simon Evans 71, Mike Collett 69, Kevin Fylan 65, Mitch Phillips 62, Miles Evans 60, Julien Pretot 57, Neil Maidment 43, Mark Meadows 42, Justin Palmer 36, Asia Sports Desk 35, Martyn Herman 7, Soxley (newbie)

Rest of the world: Maid leads on at least 91, by my reckoning, Chipking 73, and Sean got 16 last week alone, so he must be well up there. Can’t immediately find up to date numbers on anyone else. Remember, you keep your own score in this game (we trust you…) so just let us know in the comments if you’d like to be in the table. You can join any time … just see how quickly you’ll catch us up!

Without further ado, here are this week’s games. Double points this week on West Ham v Arsenal, and remember there are bonus points for style (entirely at my whim and discretion). So have at it!

Wolves v Aston Villa: Patrick Johnston 2-1, Paul Radford 0-1, Simon Evans , Mike Collett 1-3, Kevin Fylan 0-2, Mitch Phillips 0-0*, Miles Evans 1-2, Julien Pretot 1-2, Neil Maidment 0-2, Mark Meadows 0-2, JustinPalmer , Asia Sports Desk 1-1, Martyn Herman 0-1; Soxley 2-1

*Birmingham v Sunderland: Patrick Johnston 0-1, Paul Radford 0-0, Simon Evans , Mike Collett 0-1, Kevin Fylan 1-2, Mitch Phillips 2-0, Miles Evans 1-1, Julien Pretot 1-2, Neil Maidment 1-2, Mark Meadows 0-0, Justin Palmer , Asia Sports Desk 2-1, Martyn Herman 1-1; Soxley 1-2

Burnley v Wigan: Patrick Johnston 3-1, Paul Radford 3-1, Simon Evans , Mike Collett 2-2, Kevin Fylan 1-0, Mitch Phillips 0-1, Miles Evans 0-1, Julien Pretot 2-0, Neil Maidment 1-0, Mark Meadows 2-1, Justin Palmer , Asia Sports Desk 1-2, Martyn Herman 0-3; Soxley 2-0

Hull City v Portsmouth: Patrick Johnston 0-1, Paul Radford 1-0, Simon Evans , Mike Collett 0-2, Kevin Fylan 2-1, Mitch Phillips 2-0, Miles Evans 1-1, Julien Pretot 1-0, Neil Maidment 1-2, Mark Meadows 1-1, Justin Palmer , Asia Sports Desk 1-0, Martyn Herman 0-2; Soxley 1-1

Tottenham v Stoke City: Patrick Johnston 3-0 (two for Crouch), Paul Radford 1-1, Simon Evans , Mike Collett 2-0, Kevin Fylan 3-2, Mitch Phillips 3-1, Miles Evans 2-0, Julien Pretot 2-2, Neil Maidment 3-1, Mark Meadows 3-0, Justin Palmer , Asia Sports Desk 4-0, Martyn Herman 3-0; Soxley 5-1

Chelsea v Blackburn Rovers: Patrick Johnston 3-1, Paul Radford 3-0, Simon Evans , Mike Collett 3-1, Kevin Fylan 3-0, Mitch Phillips 2-0, Miles Evans 2-0, Julien Pretot 3-0, Neil Maidment 3-1, Mark Meadows 3-0, Justin Palmer , Asia Sports Desk 3-2, Martyn Herman 2-0; Soxley 3-0

Sunday:

Bolton v Everton: Patrick Johnston 2-1, Paul Radford 2-1, Simon Evans , Mike Collett 1-1, Kevin Fylan 2-2, Mitch Phillips 1-1, Miles Evans 1-2, Julien Pretot 2-2, Neil Maidment 1-1, Mark Meadows 2-1, Justin Palmer , Asia Sports Desk 2-0, Martyn Herman 2-1; Soxley 1-2

Liverpool v Manchester United: Patrick Johnston 2-1 (after five minutes injury time), Paul Radford 0-1, Simon Evans , Mike Collett 1-1, Kevin Fylan 0-3, Mitch Phillips 1-1, Miles Evans 2-2, Julien Pretot 2-1 (Mascherano, Kuyt), Neil Maidment 0-1, Mark Meadows 0-1, Justin Palmer , Asia Sports Desk 1-3, Martyn Herman 1-1; Soxley 1-3

Manchester City v Fulham: Patrick Johnston 2-0, Paul Radford 3-1, Simon Evans , Mike Collett 1-2, Kevin Fylan 3-0, Mitch Phillips 2-2, Miles Evans 3-0, Julien Pretot 2-0, Neil Maidment 2-0, Mark Meadows 2-2, Justin Palmer , Asia Sports Desk 3-0, Martyn Herman 2-0; Soxley 2-0

West Ham v Arsenal: Patrick Johnston 1-2 (Van Persie, Diaby), Paul Radford 1-3, Simon Evans , Mike Collett 0-4, Kevin Fylan 1-3, Mitch Phillips 2-2, Miles Evans 1-5, Julien Pretot 0-3, Neil Maidment 1-3, Mark Meadows 1-3, Justin Palmer , Asia Sports Desk 1-2, Martyn Herman 0-4; Soxley 0-1

PHOTO: Rubin Kazan’s Vital Kaleshin can’t believe he only got three points from last weekend’s games. REUTERS/Albert Gea

Comments

Not a lot of faith in Liverpool around. Why? I predict 2-0 and Gerrard to play.

Posted by Erica | Report as abusive
 

ive currently got 26 points so far in my three weeks, so not doing to well so far, but feeling confident with a high score again this week.Birmingham v Sunderland, 1-2Bolton v Everton, 2-2Burnley v Wigan, 2.1Chelsea v Blackburn, 2-0Hull v Portsmouth, 1.2Liverpool v Man Utd, 1.0Man City v Fulham, 3-1Tottenham v Stoke, 3.0West Ham v Arsenal, 2.3Wolverhampton v Aston Villa 0.1

Posted by sean | Report as abusive
 

31 points from three rounds, need a good week to catch up. Heres this weeks predictions:Birmingham v Sunderland 2-2Burnley v Wigan 1-0Chelsea v Blackburn 3-1Hull v Portsmouth 1-2Tottenham v Stoke 2-0Wolves v Aston Villa 1-3Bolton v Everton 1-2Liverpool v Man Utd 0-0Man City v Fulham 1-0West Ham v Arsenal 1-2

Posted by UTV | Report as abusive
 

31 points from three rounds, need a good week to catch up. Heres this weeks predictions:Birmingham v Sunderland 2-2Burnley v Wigan 1-0Chelsea v Blackburn 3-1Hull v Portsmouth 1-2Tottenham v Stoke 2-0Wolves v Aston Villa 1-3Bolton v Everton 1-2Liverpool v Man Utd 0-0Man City v Fulham 1-0West Ham v Arsenal 1-2

Posted by UTV | Report as abusive
 

have added league leader Patrick Johnston … still waiting on a couple of Reuters stragglers.UTV, will try to fix the double comment…Erica, four defeats from four tell their own story.Sean, delighted to see you on confident mood. Long may it continue!

Posted by Kevin Fylan | Report as abusive
 

birmingham 1-1 sunderlandbolton 2-1 evertonburnley 1-0 wiganchelsea 2-0 b’burnhull 1-2 pompeyl’pool 2-1 unitedcity 2-0 fulhamspurs 2-1 stokewest ham 0-2 arsenalwolves 0-2 villahope that pint at lunch didnt cloud my judgement

Posted by maid | Report as abusive
 

Home win for Liverpool … a rarity in the predictions around here. Was it the beer talking?(What did you have, by the way? I shall be enjoying a pint of Copper Dragon in the Greyhound in Tong on Sunday when I go up to visit the family. Can’t wait.)

Posted by Kevin Fylan | Report as abusive
 

that funnily enough was one of the scores i put down before lunch, just seems like the type of result you wouldnt expect the way this season is going, so im going the other way and expecting it! just hope my logic works.. just a fosters, didnt want anything above 4% or i would be in danger of putting a fulham win at city for the third year running

Posted by maid | Report as abusive
 

it would be entirely fitting in a season that just defies prediction.wise on avoiding the strong stuff. slippery slope on a friday afternoon…

Posted by Kevin Fylan | Report as abusive
 

Hoping to have a good week after last weeks appauling score so here goes….Birmingham v Sunderland, 15:00 0-2Bolton v Everton, 15:00 1-2Burnley v Wigan, 15:00 2-2Chelsea v Blackburn, 15:00 3-0Hull v Portsmouth, 15:00 1-1Liverpool v Man Utd, 15:00 2-1Man City v Fulham, 15:00 2-1Tottenham v Stoke, 15:00 2-0West Ham v Arsenal, 15:00 1-3Wolverhampton v Aston Villa, 15:00 0-2

Posted by Flip | Report as abusive
 

Good on yer, Flip. More positive thinking … and another prediction of a Liverpool win. Interesting.

Posted by Kevin Fylan | Report as abusive
 

Being a liverpool supporter couldn’t really go for a UTD win that wouldn’t go down well at all

Posted by Flip | Report as abusive
 

Birmingham v Sunderland, 0-2Bolton v Everton, 2-1Burnley v Wigan, 2-1Chelsea v Blackburn, 3-1Hull v Portsmouth, 0-3Liverpool v Man Utd, 0-2Man City v Fulham, 3-1Tottenham v Stoke, 2-0West Ham v Arsenal, 0-3Wolverhampton v Aston Villa, 1-1Need to get some big points this week after some shocking performances recently!

Posted by Chipking | Report as abusive
 

Two late entries, with interesting points-scoring implications. Mitch Phillips went for 0-0 in the Wolves v Aston Villa game after it had been on for an hour. Hmmm. Have to think about that one. May be docked for being obvious.Not so new entrant Soxley, who went for 2-1 Wolves while Villa were leading 1-0. Possible points for style there.We’ll see…

Posted by Kevin Fylan | Report as abusive
 

Wow, 2 points this week. Smashing.

Posted by julien pretot | Report as abusive
 

i see my confidents got me no were, only managing to get 2 disapointing points this week, going to have to shine next week.

Posted by sean | Report as abusive
 

7 Points for me which i am actually quite happy with considering the topsy turvy results we had this weekend, and as everyone seems to have done as bad if not worse i will gladly take the 7 gained! Puts me up to 80 now.

Posted by Chipking | Report as abusive
 

Hello folks, I predicted there would be five minutes injury time in the Liverpool v Man U game I trust that the organisers of the “lets keep Mitch Phillips happy predictions league” will add this shortly? WITCH-HUNT

Posted by Patrick | Report as abusive
 

Post Your Comment

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/
  •