You can beat Europe’s top teams but you can’t beat the Six Nations

March 22, 2009

odriscolSouthern hemisphere fans might scoff at the quality of Europe’s premier rugby competition but, yet again, the Six Nations championship has proved itself unrivalled when it comes to unpredictability and excitement.

Having waited 61 years for their second grand slam, Ireland were within seconds of having it cruelly ripped from their grasp, only for Stephen Jones’s last-minute penalty to fall short in Saturday’s nail-gnawingly tense Cardiff finale.

Had Gavin Henson been entrusted with the 48-metre kick instead of Jones, who was always straining for the distance, then Ireland might have been celebrating merely their first championship since 1985, with Wales having the consolation of a triple crown.

As it was, Ronan O’Gara’s drop-goal, and another immense performance from Brian O’Driscoll, proved decisive, and few neutrals will begrudge either great servant their moment of joy.

The 2009 championship will always be remembered as the year Ireland’s “golden generation” finally delivered, and in typical Six Nations fashion, they did it just when everyone had stopped predicting that they would do so.

They were at their best for only short spells but showed admirable tenacity and, crucially after so many heart-breaking previous near-misses, showed that they were no longer willing to play the role of plucky losers.

Wales also emerged with their honour intact, playing their part in Saturday’s memorable finale, which will also have delighted the tournament schedulers, its beleaguered sponsors and the BBC.
England enjoyed a roller-coaster tournament, ending with the high of wins over France and Scotland to secure a second successive second place.

It was the same old same old for France, who turned on the style to beat Wales and followed it up with their shocking capitulation against England.

There was little to celebrate either for the competition’s “bottom division” as Scotland managed just one win for the third season running, and Italy went backwards with a clean sweep of defeats.

The quality of the rugby on show will not have struck fear into the world champion Springboks as they prepare to welcome the British and Irish Lions but, as Johnson knows all too well from his captaincy of the 1997 Lions who beat the then-world champions South Africa, you write the Lions off at your peril.

“The whole feel of the tournament has been great and Ian McGeechan and his crew have a really good group to pick a series-winning squad from,” Johnson said on Saturday.

“He knows what he’s after and what type of person he wants on that tour. I think he’ll get a really top squad.”

PHOTO: Brian O’Driscol celebrates after Ireland’s victory over Wales at the Millennium Stadium in Cardiff, Wales March 21, 2009. REUTERS/Dylan Martinez

NOTE: We got our maths wrong first up. It was of course 61 years since¬†Ireland’s first Grand Slam, not 51, and I’ve amended accordingly. ¬†

One comment

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see

Agreed. Four teams could have won this year’s edition, and the same four will contest it next year. And each team only has one pop at the other five. This makes it a better tournament than the Tri-Nations. People may go on about the Southern Hemisphere’s superior quality, highlighted last year when only Wales pulled off a victory against the Aussies, but a look back at the last two World Cups shows you who’s on top. England in both finals, Australia and South Africa in one each, supposed world-beaters New Zealand in a mere semi-final, France in both semis. Fanks.

Posted by Graham | Report as abusive