17th at Sawgrass — gimmick or greatest finish in golf?

May 5, 2009

Tiger Woods and Adam Scott have described it as gimmicky. Phil Mickelson believes it is the midway point in golf’s most exciting finish but former British Open champion Mark Calcavecchia says it has the same effect as a nervous wait for a nasty dental appointment.

It is the infamous par-three 17th at the TPC Sawgrass in Ponte Vedra Beach, Florida, the signature hole on the Stadium Course which will host the Players Championship this week for the 28th time.

Sergio Garcia of Spain and his caddie walk from the island green on the 17th hole during first round play of The Players Championship in Ponte Vedra

Arguably more photographed than any other hole in golf, the 17th strikes fear into the heart of every competitor at the tournament regarded by the players as the unofficial fifth major.

Although the smallest hole on the par-72 Stadium layout, it unquestionably boasts the biggest reputation with its tantalising island green that narrows to the right side.

Shot selection is paramount, especially in the wind, and the tournament has often been decided there, a bone of contention for world number one Woods.

“It’s a wonderful hole but I don’t agree with it being the 17th or 71st hole of a championship because I think it’s a little gimmicky in that sense,” said the American, whose only victory at Sawgrass came in 2001.

“I think it’s a great eighth hole or another part of the golf course. It’s a challenge. There’s no getting around it, you have to hit the proper shot to the proper distance.”

Australian Scott, who won the 2004 title, accepts the hole’s unusual challenge.

“It’s part of this event and it’s one of the reasons why this event has become what it is,” he said.

“Playing it is not that much fun but to watch it is probably a lot of fun. It’s a gimmick to have an island green like that but … it’s still pretty fair. It’s a big green.”

Woods walks to the island green on the 17th hole in front of a large gallery during second play of the Tournament Players Championship in Ponte Vedra Beach

Three-times major winner Mickelson loves the 17th hole just the way it is.

“I think it adds for the most exciting finish in golf, combined with 16 and 18, and I wouldn’t recommend any changes,” the American left-hander said.

“Seventeen provides a great chance for a birdie, but also a double bogey or worse. This is one of the few holes that I can think of that has no bail-out, no margin of error, no area for recovery. It’s an all-or-nothing type shot.”

For the players, surviving 17 is like walking a circus tightrope without a net. The slightest of miscalculations, or perhaps even a sudden switch in the breeze, can result in a big number and a ruined scorecard.

“It’s like having a three o’clock appointment for a root canal,” 1989 British Open champion Calcavecchia said.

“You’re thinking about it all morning and you feel (bad) all day. You kind of know that, sooner or later, you’ve got to get to it.”

What’s your take on the par-three 17th? Is it good or bad for the Players Championship?

Pictures of Sergio Garcia (top) and Tiger Woods at the hole in question by Hans Deryk


We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/

There are hazards lurking all over that course, so for Woods to say it would be better placed as the eighth hole is ludicrous.
It’s certainly no gimmick, but neither is it the greatest finish in golf. So what is the greatest finish in golf then?? Tough one to call..St Andrews? Pebble Beach?

Posted by Tom | Report as abusive

definitely a great finish


Posted by jack | Report as abusive

A golf course in South Africa, built with the idea of attracting tourists could possibly hold the distinction of the most extreme golf hole in all of golf. The tee sits 1400 feet above the green and a player needs to take a chopper up to the tee box. The airtime of the ball in itself lasts almost an eternity and then the challenge of finding the green down below. Padraig Harrington, recently, managed to make par on that hole, a hug achievement by any standards.

Often people are so enamoured by a golf course’s beauty, so much so that they fall in love with it. Yet, there is at least one hole on a golf course that catches the designer’s fancy. Referred to as the signature hole, it perhaps best describes what the course designer fancies as the most fascinating challenge, sculpted in a way to show his course in all its glory.

And these are just two of the many that catch the fancy of golf enthusiasts across the world. Some holes are pure bliss because of the sights it offers that could blow you away, others, perhaps, for the history they carry with it but undoubtedly all these golf holes add that extra bit of charm to the fable that goes by the name of golf.

Posted by Andy Brown of HomeofGolf.TV | Report as abusive

I’m aware if I’m playing at my best I’m tough to beat. And I enjoy that. – Tiger Woods www.allthequotes.com/TigerWoods.php

Posted by AllTheQuotes | Report as abusive

golf hole…

Your topic Gift Idea: Hole in One Golf Bag | On Par for Retirement … was interesting when I found it on Thursday searching for golf hole…

Posted by golf hole | Report as abusive