UPDATE: Does Big Mac belong in the Hall of Fame?

January 11, 2010

Former St. Louis Cardinals star Mark McGwire is sworn in to testimony at the House of Representatives hearing on Government Reform in Washington, March 17, 2005.

In a statement sent to various news outlets on Monday Mark McGwire finally admitted what many had already suspected.

“I used steroids during my playing career and I apologize,” McGwire said in the release.  “I wish I had never touched steroids. It was foolish and it was a mistake. I truly apologize. Looking back, I wish I had never played during the steroid era.”

McGwire said his decision to talk about his steroid use was prompted by his new position as St. Louis’ hitting coach.

McGwire said he feels he has an obligation to talk about this part of his career and answer questions.

Not what McGwire has apologized and is willing to talk about his transgressions, does this change his HOF chances or does this solidify his place as nothing more than a cheat who has no place in Cooperstown?

Original post: Hank Aaron, Babe Ruth, Willie Mays and Frank Robinson. That’s it, the complete list of players who are in the Baseball Hall of Fame (HOF) that have more career home runs than Mark McGwire, after he again fell short in this, his fourth year of eligibility. McGwire received only 23.7 percent of the vote, well shy of the 75 percent needed for Hall entry.

Some have tried to argue that McGwire is not Hall worthy because he was a one-dimensional player. Well this is simply ludicrous. McGwire led the league in walks twice and his career .394 on base percentage ranks 64th highest all-time since 1901. Furthermore, his 1414 career RBI is well above the average number for HOF hitters and he was a 12-time All Star. He also captured a Gold Glove in 1990.

At the very least McGwire had two dimensions to his game, power and the ability to get on base. David Pinto of Baseball Musings feels there are only three dimensions to hitting, so two out of three is pretty good.

The only logical explanation for McGwire’s exclusion from Cooperstown are the suspicions that have dogged him about performance enhancing drugs (PEDs).

McGwire has never admitted to using PEDs or failed a drug test, but his name was mentioned in Sen. George Mitchell’s investigation into steroids use in Major League Baseball.

During his testimony on March 17, 2005 before the House Government Reform Committee to discuss the use of steroids in baseball, McGwire declined to answer questions under oath.  “I’m not here to talk about the past. I’m here to be positive about this subject,” he said.

The easiest way for McGwire to gain traction in his HOF candidacy, some observers say,  would be to address the issue head on. Andy Pettitte admitted to using HGH and his career has recovered nicely. He was even given the honor of being the starting pitcher in the last game at the old Yankee Stadium.

On the other hand Roger Clemens, who vehemently denies he ever took steroids or any other banned substance, has had his name removed from a Houston hospital, has been asked to end his affiliation with a charity golf tournament and will likely face the same HOF rejection McGwire has.

With his recent appointment as the Cardinal’s hitting coach, McGwire has a fantastic opportunity to address the issue properly. If he does not do so in a satisfactory manner early in his tenure, questions about his past will continue to plague him.

Baseball is a game built around numbers. Joe DiMaggio’s 56-game hitting streak, Cy Young’s 511 career wins, Nolan Ryan’s seven no-hitters, Rickey Henderson’s 1,406 career stolen bases. They are all in the HOF. To say McGwire’s not Hall worthy because he doesn’t have the numbers is insane.


We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/

“Power and Ability to get on base” are inextricably tied together.

“Receiving a base on balls does not count as a hit or an at bat for a batter but does count as a time on base and a plate appearance. Therefore, a base on balls does not increase nor decrease a player’s batting average, but it does increase his on-base percentage.” Wikipedia

If you are a power hitter, you get walked a lot. Even if it wasn’t intentional, pitchers tend to pitch around good hitters.

And well, Home Runs = RBI’s

So in effect, he IS a one-dimensional player.

If he had a couple more Golden Gloves, and had simply answered “No” to the steroid question instead of making the following statement to Congress, I would consider the issue settled.

“Asking me or any other player to answer questions about who took steroids in front of television cameras will not solve the problem. If a player answers ‘No,’ he simply will not be believed; if he answers ‘Yes,’ he risks public scorn and endless government investigations…. My lawyers have advised me that I cannot answer these questions without jeopardizing my friends, my family, and myself. I will say, however, that it remains a fact in this country that a man, any man, should be regarded as innocent unless proven guilty.” -McGwire (Wikipedia)

(I don’t like using wikipedia but for this it will do)

Posted by charlesv | Report as abusive

No Hall for any Drug user’s ever

Posted by acordas | Report as abusive