Romney, Sully, Steve Jobs and The Boss
By Steven Brill
This is the first entry in a new regular column, “Stories I’d Like To See.” It’s the notebook of someone who still thinks like an editor but is over the thrill of managing a reporting staff â or the hassle of dealing with âgreatâ story ideas that crash and burn when someone actually goes out and reports them and learns anew that even the best editors canât hit much better than the best ballplayers (meaning three or four out of ten story ideas will actually work).
1. Mitt the philanthropist:
If the excellent New York Times story last month about Mitt Romneyâs Mormon Church involvement is correct, he is required to tithe 10 percent of his income to the Church or church activities each year. This would amount to an enormous amount of money when he was running Bain Capital during its highly-successful years. It might even make him the most charitable person ever to run for President (or be President). Is this true? Or did he tithe 10 percent of his âtaxable income,â which would have been a lot less, given all the deductions and favorable tax-rate-treatment available to a high-income private-equity earner?
2. Mitt the taxpayer:
On the other hand, this raises the issue of what percentage of his gross earnings Romney paid in taxes during his best years, or even last year, when presumably all of his earnings were capital gains and might also have been subject to all kinds of investment tax credit and other deductions. I know he hasnât released his tax returns (yet), but canât someone get access to Bainâs investor reports and an estimate of his gross income, and then extrapolate that into what he actually might have paid, given favorable tax treatment of capital gains and of carried interest payouts to private equity fund managers? Or, at least, canât some pesky reporter simply pick Bainâs best two or three years when he was running it and ask Romney what percent of federal income tax he paid on his gross income?
3. Yankeesâ empty seats:
During this yearâs baseball season, as anyone who watched their games on television could readily see, many of Yankee Stadiumâs prime seats, which once carried a price tag of $2,500 per game, went empty. Now, I hear the team is calling around to former box holders offering deals. Is this true? More broadly, three years into its run, how is the new Stadium doing financially? And, how are the Yankees doing financially? Are things being run differently since the death of George Steinbrenner? Canât somebody find one of the Yankeesâ limited partners to spill the beans?
4. Medical insurance trophy:
Whatâs the most medically-dubious but expensive procedure paid for by Medicare, and who lobbied for it? How much does it cost per year? Which bureaucrats make those decisions and do they go through the usual revolving door in and out of the companies whose products and services they evaluate?
5. Litigation system test:
As we approach the third anniversary of the successful crash-landing of a U.S. Airways jet into the Hudson River on January 15, Iâd like to know if any of the passengers sued the airline or anyone else after pilot Sully Sullenbergerâs heroic landing and his crewâs equally heroic evacuation of all the passengers. If ever there was a case where âvictimsâ were the victims of bad luck but not negligence (except on the part of the birds that flew into the planeâs engines), this seems to be it. So, did anyone sue or threaten to sue to get the airline or the airport or someone else to pay for their bad luck? Or is this a case where litigious Americans and usually-ferocious air-crash accident plaintiffsâ lawyers all took a pass?
6. When good news is bad news:
Iâve lately been seeing stock analystsâ reports covering major defense contractors that have been awfully gloomy over the news that we are winding down the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan. I would love to see a story quoting a bunch of them spelling out â artfully or inartfully â how peace is bad news. And what are they saying about the chances of those Draconian defense cuts mandated by Mondayâs failure of the supercommittee actually happening?
7. Gatesâs real legacy:
Walter Isaacsonâs vivid biography of Steve Jobs quotes Jobs dismissing Bill Gates as having created boring, pedestrian products, and for generally being a soul-less geek who would have been better off had he dropped acid at some point in his life. Itâs fun to read this kind of smug dis of the worldâs richest man. But thereâs nothing soulless about Gatesâs and his wife Melindaâs post-Microsoft life, running what is now the worldâs richest and arguably most-effective foundation. Iâd love to see a story taking us to a village in Africa where we can meet the children whom Gatesâs fortune is protecting from malaria or dysentery, or to a classroom in Memphis where his money is priming the pump for effective school reform. Not as wondrous as watching Kim Kardashian work a smartphone, but pretty compelling stuff.
Reporter Alert: Donât let the hyper-protective Gates Foundation PR department orchestrate this as a tour of the Gateses going through some village or sitting in a classroom smiling at their beneficiaries. Just show up, and get deep into the nitty-gritty of how they have not only been generous with their billions but also have been geekily efficient and relentless in diving personally into the details of making their programs work. I found in doing my recent book about the battle over fixing American public education that Bill and Melinda sweated the small stuff related to their education reform grants Â â the same way Isaacson watched Jobs agonize over whether iPhones should have square or round corners.
Photos: Republican presidential candidate Romney serves sandwiches to supporters outside Jackie’s Diner in Nashua, New Hampshire. REUTERS/Brian Snyder.Â A section of premium seats can be seen empty in the New York Yankees stadium during an MLB baseball game against the Cleveland Indians at Yankee Stadium in New York.Â REUTERS/Lucas Jackson.
See one of these stories come to fruition? Have an idea of your own? Drop a note in the comments below.