Name-recalling in healthcare fight: Wellstone, Kennedy

August 28, 2009

The healthcare fight has turned into a power struggle over names.

Conservatives have the sirens out warning about the “Wellstone effect” in a jab at trying to knock out any inclination Liberals may have to capitalize on the Kennedy name in pursuing healthcare overhaul, one of  Senator Edward Kennedy’s signature issues. MEMORIAL WELLSTONE

Trouble is that the Wellstone analogy doesn’t automatically jump out for everyone.

It takes a bit of digging into the memory banks (or perhaps Googling) to refresh the brain cells that the reference is to the 2002 memorial service for Democrat Senator Paul Wellstone which was criticized for turning into a political event. Backlash contributed to Democrats losing that Senate seat.

Conservatives may be worrying that the emotional effect from Senator Edward Kennedy’s death may swing the healthcare debate toward the left, especially after Senator Robert Byrd proposed stamping Kennedy’s name on the legislation.

But analysts say while the Kennedy name is powerful, it is unlikely to shift the balance in the healthcare debate.

“I don’t think it will bring any Republicans aboard, they have decided not to legislate, but to oppose and to kill (healthcare reform). And it may stiffen the spine of a few Democrats,” Thomas Mann, senior fellow of governance studies at The Brookings Institution, said.

Click here for more Reuters political coverage

Photo credit: Reuters/Eric Miller (Memorial service for Wellstone in 2002)


We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see

I want to be able to buy the same :” socialized healthcare coverage as my” Honorable Senators and Congressman” have on my hard earned tax dollars.
Why should they be different than us ordinary hard working over taxed citizens ?
FROM AN Overtaxed old man.

Posted by Michael Kovacs | Report as abusive

Senior citizen’s health care will be cut so that illegal aliens can have government healthcare. It will cost well over one trillion dollars, probably two. Government has never be good at saving money.
Why can’t we just limit malpractice suits payouts, improve competition with interstate HMO choices and private co-ops. If there is rationing let it be on the illegal aliens not the seniors.

Posted by rick | Report as abusive