Broken clocks, laryngitis at the Supreme Court

November 2, 2009

In a place where the time to argue some of the most important legal issues in the United States is pivotal yet limited, clocks throughout the Supreme Court building were not working on Monday — including the big one behind the bench that attorneys arguing their case and that spectators in the audience can see.

After the justices went on the bench at 10 a.m., Chief Justice John Roberts noted the problem and pointed out that attorneys are sometimes told not to look at the clock during oral arguments. “That is particularly important today,” he said.

USA/Court spokeswoman Kathy Arberg said the problem stemmed from a “malfunction” with the court’s master clock. It apparently occurred when the clocks were to be turned back over the weekend for the end of daylight saving time.

Clocks in the building finally were fixed by the time the court heard arguments in a third case in the early afternoon.

Besides a broken clock, the arguments in the first case, a dispute over excessive fees charged to mutual fund investors, also produced another unusual development — the admission from Justice Stephen Breyer that he has laryngitis.

While asking a question, Breyer made a mistake and said the court was reversing — instead of reviewing — a federal judge’s opinion.

“I have laryngitis. I don’t speak accurately,” the hoarse-sounding Breyer told the lawyer as the courtroom erupted in laughter.

Click here for more Reuters political coverage.

– Photo credit: Reuters/Jim Young


We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see

Who the hell ever heard of holding a public office for life? That smacks of divine right. It needs to be done away with immediately. Judges are not gods; they are neither better nor more deserving of respect than the rest of us.

Posted by Mufaso | Report as abusive

If you need justice, it seems the clocks are broken at all the US Courts.

Posted by james Reginald Harris, Jr | Report as abusive

Hey Mufaso, why don’t you look up the history of the drafting of the Constitution before you spout off your ignorance? I will agree with you, though, that some certain current justices do seem to believe themselves divinely inspired in their jurisprudence.

Posted by borisjimbo | Report as abusive

A joke: the great American has created a financial crisis.
Sets of light all over the world of money and do not add any
to spread the prevention and control of the H1N1 influenza virus,
killed a lot of people’s lives around the world. The United States,
I support you.

Posted by honghong | Report as abusive

Well Mufaso, Who would you want to be there Mr. Lionel Hutz.

Posted by DAVID | Report as abusive