Are the financial markets really Europe’s savior?
If the euro is saved, the much-maligned power of global financial markets will deserve much of the credit.
The conventional wisdom among many on the intellectual left is that unbridled financial players threaten to destroy the European Union, one of historyâs noblest, war-ending projects. The truth, however, is something else. To be sure, speculators lack noble motives, and global capital is a blunt instrument that tends to overshoot. But markets are forcing European leaders to fix their fatally flawed monetary union, a union that can only last with deeper economic integration and greater political (and democratic) legitimacy.
Last weekendâs agreement by Spain to accept a bank bailout, based on a European aid package of $125 billion, is a dramatic case in point. Senior Obama administration officials, in a series of urgent conversations with their European counterparts, warned that Spain posed the possibility of a âLehman moment,â with global reverberations that no one could predict. If European leaders didnât demonstrate to markets that they would pool their resources to address the banking meltdown of Europeâs fourth-largest economy, the contagion could have spread, what remained of U.S. and global growth could have evaporated, and the European Union itself would have been endangered.
In retrospect, it may have been wiser to build Europe without a common currency, one senior Obama administration official told me, given all the historical and national differences. However, now that the euro is used by 17 countries and has become a global reserve currency, the euro zone canât be dismantled without unacceptable European and global risk. Thus, U.S. officials had been urging European leaders to settle the Spanish bank crisis before the Greek election next Sunday, June 17, and the G-20 meeting June 18-19, to avoid convening on the brink of financial catastrophe.
In the end, however, it wasnât President Obama who forced a Spain deal through his lobbying with the top three euro country leaders â Chancellor Angela Merkel, French President FranĂ§ois Hollande and Italian President Mario Monti. (Side note: One does wonder whether British Prime Minister David Cameron isnât beginning to feel left out). Instead, it was the unrelenting pressure of European and global creditors and investors, who were withdrawing in droves from Spain, unsure whether a German-led Europe would provide the financial bazooka required.
The simple fact is that Europe some time ago ceased having a true monetary union. Although no country has withdrawn from the euro, markets have quit treating it as a trusted, common currency. As Irish economist Colm McCarthy writes: âEuropeâs single financial market has been sundered through deposit flight and nation-by-nation re-matching of assets and liabilities.â
At an event jointly hosted by the Atlantic Council and Germanyâs Suddeutsche Zeitung on Friday, IMF chiefÂ Christine Lagarde worried about political cycles running behind economic and market cycles, as âa movie we have watched one too many times.â
It looks something like this. Tensions escalate and, out of necessity, policy makers take action. But just enough for the danger to subside. Then the urgency is lost, momentum wanes, then the policy discourse begins to fracture, too focused on their own backyards and not enough on the big picture. And so tensions start to rise again.
But, with the passing of each cycle, we reach a higher and higher level of uncertainty, and the stakes rise. At this point, stability is at stake. Growth is at stake. In the case of Europe, the cycles are now threatening the very existence of the European project.
Markets tell politicians what they donât want to hear. Economist Jean Pisani-Ferry says bond markets wonât be convinced until they see Europe has a banking union (Europe-wide banking supervision, deposit insurance, and crisis resolution), sufficient tax pooling (so that EU-level institutions can take charge of financial stability), and mutualization of enough of the costs of the crisisÂ to convince markets that their bets against the euro are in vain.
Markets will continue to test Europeâs leaders until they are convinced they are committed to correcting their systemâs flaws. And resisting markets is like complaining about the rain, and this one is a deluge. Global markets have a weight that no one anticipated when the Maastricht Treaty created the single currency in 1992. Â Since then, global financial stock has quadrupled through 2010 to $212 trillion, from $54 trillion in 1990, according to the McKinsey Global Institute. More stunning yet, Lagarde says the total amount of outstanding OTC derivatives in 2011 was $648 trillion in 2011, compared with just $12.1 trillion in 1992.
Josef Ackermann, former Deutsche Bank chief executive and now chairman of Zurich Insurance Group, said at the Atlantic Council last week that markets have done Europe a favor by forcing upon it financial and structural reforms and greater discipline. âThereâs no politician who stood up and said we have to change that â not one,â he said. Without markets shifting credit spreads, he believes Greek profligacy would have gone on for some more years. âWeâve completely changed the discipline of European countries going forward, and thatâs a good thing.â
Beyond that, however, he says politicians need to do much more to convince voters of Europeâs value. âA fragmented Europe has no way for self-determination,â he warned. âWe will have to accept what the United States, China, India, Brazil and other countries [dictate to] us. This cannot be the future of our children.â
If Europe manages this crisis successfully, Ackermann argues, it will instill a new self-confidence that will express itself globally as Europe jointly conquers a historic challenge. Conversely, it follows that failure could dramatically reduce Europeâs influence and unity for at least a generation to come.
PHOTO:Â A demonstrator hangs fake Euro notes on her leg during a protest against Spain’s bailout at La Constitucion square in Malaga, southern Spain, June 10, 2012. REUTERS/Jon Nazca