It’s not unusual after presidential debate full of fireworks and mud slinging, but political pundits were a bit divided over who won the Republican faceoff last night although some said surging Mike Huckabee did one heckuva job.
NBC News’ First Read argued the former Arkansas governor sounded presidential from the beginning and stepped up his game.
“He had his share of one-liners — the best being the one about Jesus would never have run for higher office — but he seemed to balance the funny with more presidential rhetoric,” it said.
The widely watched Des Moines Register political columnist David Yepsen said Huckabee, John McCain and Fred Thompson were the three winners last night while front runners Mitt Romney and Rudy Giuliani didn’t have such great a evening.
“The Romney-Giuliani tiff with each other over sanctuary cities at the beginning of the evening diminished them both because it didn’t look very presidential,” Yepsen wrote.
Political watchers at CNN, which hosted the debate, were more divided: Gloria Borger said there was no clear winner while Democratic strategist Jamal Simmons said McCain did the best. Republican conservative Bill Bennett argued Romney outperformed them all.
Tell us who you think did the best and why…


Trackback
3 comments so far
I believe Mike Huckabee and Rudy Giuliani had the strongest showings at the recent Republican Presidential Debate on 11/28/07. Both of them had clearly defined stances on the issues and did not mince words in expressing their stances. Mr. Huckabee really impressed me with his quick witted humor and ability to voice his views in a clear concise manner. Mr. Giuliani impressed me with his recollection of numbers and statistics when discussing his record of success as mayor of NYC. I feel Mitt Romney and Tom Tancredo had the poorest showings. Mr Romney seemed to fumble for words on more than one occassion and seemed to want to attack the other candidates as oppossed to telling the audience what his position was on several issues. Mr Tancredo did not seem very presidential in his comments and demeanor. I think he probably alienated himself from many voters.
- Posted by AndrewMitt Romney shinned the brightest. Rudy attacked him and then got his mudd shoved back down his throat. I wonder if every time Rudy caught a cab in NY he checked the cab drivers green card? Romney is the only one who answered the bible question without pandering. If you are a Christian the answer is simple you either believe or you dont- simple! He is a true leader with a clear and feasable plan. He is more than words—he is action and unlike HUckabee, he proved it in MA> Huckabee flat out lied on taxes and he has more ethical skeletons than Nixon. Romney won hands down. CNN wants Huck as the winner because CNN is a dem network… of course they want Huckabee or McCain they would be the easiest for the clinton money and political machine to beat. The only candidate that can stand toe to toe with hill is Romney. HE does not have any dirt for clinton to throw and that scares the hell out of the dems
- Posted by AshleyWhy is there no mention of Dr. Ron Paul at all?
According to CNN’s website, he overwhelmingly won in their online CNN/youtube debate polls:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T5hQoTAxg qI&feature=related
http://www.cnn.com/ELECTION/2008/debates /scorecard/youtube.debate.112807/result s.html
Who is Ron Paul?
- Posted by CaptainAmerica1776