Brown’s Scotland likely to be hit worst in recession

November 7, 2008

The Labour Party may have won the Glenrothes by-election this week, partly on the back of the Prime Minister’s handling of the financial crisis, but Gordon Brown’s Scotland is predicted to suffer more than the rest of Britain during the economic downturn.

Scotland was named European Region of the Future for the second time in four years by the Financial Times’ fDi (foreign direct investment) magazine this year.

But figures show its growth is likely to lag behind the rest of the UK during the oncoming recession.

According to the Scottish Item Club’s 2008 Economic Prospects report, the Scottish economy is estimated to have grown 1.8 percent in 2008, 0.3 percent less than the UK’s rate. By 2009, this gap will have worsened to 0.6 percent. 

The main reason is the Scottish economy’s vulnerability to a weakening financial services sector.

This sector has been the driving force behind the country’s growth during the past decade, providing tens of thousands of jobs. Since 1998, its output has represented more than 8 percent of total Scottish GDP, and it has grown at an average annual rate of 7.3 percent.

But the result of a more cautious banking sector is likely to be a drop in financial services growth to only 2.9 percent in 2008. 

The situation has not been helped by the likely takeover of HBOS, which includes the Bank of Scotland, by Lloyds TSB, with an expected swathe of jobs cuts in its Edinburgh head office.

The banking sector accounts for more than 10 percent of Britain’s financial services employment, the Item Club said.

Secretary of State for Scotland Jim Murphy told Reuters the sector faced “specific challenges” because of the economy’s concentration in that area.

“That sector is feeling the most,” he said.

“But Gordon Brown has said he will do everything it takes to support it.”

Other factors are likely to worsen the situation, the report added, such as a slowing down in the growth of public spending, the lagged impact of interest rate rises since August 2006, persistently high real oil prices and slowing U.S. and European economies.

Construction, another area of relative strength in Scotland in recent years, has also been growing more slowly than its UK counterpart.

Investment is forecast to drop sharply over the coming year, CBI Scotland said last week, and manufacturers are reporting problems accessing internal finance, the Financial Times reported.

“In the coming year economic conditions in the UK will provide a much tougher backdrop for the Scottish economy as the impact of the credit crunch ripples out to other sectors of the economy,” the report added.

“If a return to sluggish growth is confirmed, then it raises questions on how Scotland will perform in a much less benign environment, with financial services in the developed world at the epicentre of slowing growth and public spending growth under much more pressure than at any time in this decade,” the report went on to say.

People living in Brown’s constituency, a former coal mining area, have felt a decline for the past 20 years, including the decade of economic growth Brown presided over as Chancellor.

William Anderson, a 52-year-old psychiatrist nurse, said the motto in Kirkcaldy was “home, dole, giro” – referring to the reliance on the state in the area.

“Shops and pubs are closing,” he said. “The social scene is disappearing.

You now get two and three generations of families unemployed. There is rough housing and crime. My parents don’t go out after 6pm anymore. There is generally a bad feeling, a negative feeling since the 80s.”

The Scottish National Party, which has a majority in the Scottish Parliament, has devised a six-point plan to help Scotland avoid the worst effects of recession, the Financial Times said.

These include bringing forward capital projects to stimulate construction and the housing industry, boosting energy efficiency and improving advice to businesses and streamlining the planning process.

But the sense of a recession has already hit Glenrothes.

Murray Pearson, a retired company director, shopping in one of Scotland’s biggest indoor retail centres, said most people were only looking, not buying.

“There are plenty of people about,” he said. “But they are not spending, and they are going to cheaper places.

“We are definitely cutting back on Christmas — everything is so expensive.”

One comment

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see

No doubt this will lead to even greater transfers of taxpayers’ money from England to Scotland. Heads the Scots win, tails the English lose. An independent England would be free of this burden of liabilities and ingratitude, and an independent Scotland would have to learn to provide for itself. We would all win.

Posted by Oliver Chettle | Report as abusive