Vipul Tripathi

Vipul Tripathi's Profile

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce?

July 12, 2009

More than 130 people died after consuming bootleg liquor in Gujarat last week.

While prohibition is in place in Gujarat, liquor is often smuggled in from neighbouring states and people are forced to buy it at inflated prices.

What can the poor do? They cannot afford to buy branded alcohol so they consume illicit liquor. Plastic pouches called ‘potlis’ of illegally brewed liquor are available for as little as ten rupees.

Some have said that Gujarat’s prohibition policy encourages bootlegging. Liquor baron Vijay Mallya argues that apart from loss of revenue this leads to “illegal, unhygienic and unsupervised production of deadly cocktails which claim innocent lives.”

During the Great Depression, the ‘Noble Experiment’ prohibition policy in the United States was repealed just 14 years after the sale of alcohol was banned.

An article in the Foreign Policy magazine, a couple of years ago, argued:

“A ‘drug-free world,’ which the United Nations describes as a realistic goal, is no more attainable than an ‘alcohol-free world’ – and no one has talked about that with a straight face since the repeal of Prohibition in the United States in 1933.”

In the context of legalising use of marijuana, author and journalist Christopher Hitchens argues that:

“It’s beyond the competence of the state to decide a question like this. You can’t hope the government to go out and control what substance somebody puts in their own body. So even if I thought that marijuana was poisonous I would still say the government is not going to be able to stop it, so it shouldn’t try.”

In the 1990s, Andhra Pradesh took up and abandoned the prohibition policy in less than two years.

“Despite our best efforts, the prohibition-related offences, particularly illicit distillation and smuggling, have been steadily increasing in the state,” the state Excise minister said when the ban was being lifted.

In New Delhi, you have to be above twenty-five years of age to be legally served alcohol in a bar.

I have been occasionally asked for identification but have got away with a little bit of bluster. I am well over twenty-five but bartenders have no means of confirming it if

I refuse to produce proof of my age.

The age policy  is routinely flouted.

In Gujarat, the more resourceful “get a medical certificate from a designated civil surgeon, who prescribes a dose of liquor necessary for curing an ailment.”

The Constitution mandates in Part Four (carrying the legally unenforceable provisions which ideally should be enforced by governments):

“To bring about the prohibition of intoxicating drinks and drugs that are injurious to health.”

If banning alcohol puts people in the way of more harmful drinks, then is the government fulfilling the constitutional mandate?

One comment so far

TGgrOO jscoorvzspni, [url=http://zjbsovvrtoks.com/]zjbsovvrto ks[/url], [link=http://zfringnfsqbh.com/]zfringnfs qbh[/link], http://zczjpmeusdeg.com/

- Posted by dnrobecpz

mulberry wallets…

I was more than happy to find this internet-site.I wanted to thanks in your time for this glorious learn!! I undoubtedly having fun with each little bit of it and I’ve you bookmarked to take a look at new stuff you weblog post….

- Posted by mulberry wallets

NoGILRLW…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by NoGILRLW

MICHAEL KORS BAGS…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by MICHAEL KORS BAGS

DIABLO 3 GOLD…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by DIABLO 3 GOLD

Cheap Beats by Dre…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by Cheap Beats by Dre

Pig…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by Pig

Ray Ban Sunglasses Outlet…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by Ray Ban Sunglasses Outlet

LOUIS VUITTON SACS SOLDES…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by LOUIS VUITTON SACS SOLDES

COACH OUTLET…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by COACH OUTLET

Christian Louboutin Shoes…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by Christian Louboutin Shoes

cheap oakley sunglasses…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by cheap oakley sunglasses

nike free run…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by nike free run

整形美容…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by 整形美容

LOUIS VUITTON OUTLET…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by LOUIS VUITTON OUTLET

louis vuitton pas cher…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by louis vuitton pas cher

CHEAP IPHONE 5…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by CHEAP IPHONE 5

christian louboutin outlet…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by christian louboutin outlet

cheap jordans…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by cheap jordans

SEO TOOLS…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by SEO TOOLS

burberry bags…

–…

- Posted by burberry bags

ralph lauren polo…

–…

- Posted by ralph lauren polo

cheap ray ban sunglasses,fake ray ban sunglasses,replica ray ban sunglasses…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by cheap ray ban sunglasses,fake ray ban sunglasses,replica ray ban sunglasses

Cheap Vibram Five Fingers…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by Cheap Vibram Five Fingers

ルイヴィトン財布…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by ルイヴィトン財布

JEREMY SCOTT ADIDAS…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by JEREMY SCOTT ADIDAS

LOUIS VUITTON HANDBAGS…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by LOUIS VUITTON HANDBAGS

JIMMY CHOO BLACK LEATHER…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by JIMMY CHOO BLACK LEATHER

cheap louis vuitton bags…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by cheap louis vuitton bags

prada bags…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by prada bags

buy wow gold…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by buy wow gold

MULBERRY SALE…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by MULBERRY SALE

Vibram FiveFingers Flow…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by Vibram FiveFingers Flow

Vibram Five Finger Sale…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by Vibram Five Finger Sale

vibram five fingers outlet…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by vibram five fingers outlet

AIR JORDAN?4…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by AIR JORDAN?4

handbags hermes…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by handbags hermes

chanel purse…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by chanel purse

herve leger gowns…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by herve leger gowns

scarf hermes…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by scarf hermes

oakley sunglasses outlet…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by oakley sunglasses outlet

mbt?footwear…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by mbt?footwear

Ghd Hair Straightener…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by Ghd Hair Straightener

Chanel Purses Handbags…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by Chanel Purses Handbags

Handbag Hermes…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by Handbag Hermes

GHD Outlet…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by GHD Outlet

Herve Leger…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by Herve Leger

hermes bag…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by hermes bag

mbt sandals…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by mbt sandals

Herve Leger Sale…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by Herve Leger Sale

chanel buy…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by chanel buy

CHANEL PERFUME…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by CHANEL PERFUME

chanel handbags…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by chanel handbags

KELLY HANDBAG HERMES…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by KELLY HANDBAG HERMES

herve leger clothing…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by herve leger clothing

bag chanel…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by bag chanel

Hermes Birkin Handbag…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by Hermes Birkin Handbag

hermes scarf…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by hermes scarf

air jordan outlet…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by air jordan outlet

air jordan?nike…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by air jordan?nike

bandage dresses herve leger…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by bandage dresses herve leger

mbt mens shoes…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by mbt mens shoes

hermes kelly handbag…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by hermes kelly handbag

BIRKIN HERMES BAG…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by BIRKIN HERMES BAG

hermes birkin…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by hermes birkin

hermes birkin purse…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by hermes birkin purse

Air Jordan?1…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by Air Jordan?1

RUN FREE NIKE…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by RUN FREE NIKE

Kelly Hermes Bag…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by Kelly Hermes Bag

ghd?straighteners…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by ghd?straighteners

Handbags Chanel…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by Handbags Chanel

mbt womens shoes…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by mbt womens shoes

DRESS HERVE LEGER…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by DRESS HERVE LEGER

herve leger clothes…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by herve leger clothes

Herve Leger Bandage Dresses…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by Herve Leger Bandage Dresses

ISABEL MARANT SNEAKERS PAS CHER…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by ISABEL MARANT SNEAKERS PAS CHER

AIR JORDAN RETRO…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by AIR JORDAN RETRO

Buy Chanel…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by Buy Chanel

Ralph Lauren…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by Ralph Lauren

nike run free…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by nike run free

air jordan?sneakers…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by air jordan?sneakers

air jordan shoes…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by air jordan shoes

GHD HAIR OUTLET…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by GHD HAIR OUTLET

nike free mens…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by nike free mens

mulberry handbags…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by mulberry handbags

NIKE FREE SHOES…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by NIKE FREE SHOES

nike running free…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by nike running free

BIRKIN BAGS HERMES…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by BIRKIN BAGS HERMES

HERMES BAG BIRKIN…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by HERMES BAG BIRKIN

herve leger bandage…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by herve leger bandage

fake oakley sunglasses…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by fake oakley sunglasses

Beats By Dre Outlet…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by Beats By Dre Outlet

Cheap Ipad Mini…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by Cheap Ipad Mini

Air Jordan?5…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by Air Jordan?5

free 5.0 nike…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by free 5.0 nike

hermes purses…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by hermes purses

hermes birkin kelly…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by hermes birkin kelly

d3 gold…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by d3 gold

SEO…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by SEO

cheap ipad 4…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by cheap ipad 4

Mulberry Bags Outlet…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by Mulberry Bags Outlet

sherri hill dresses…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by sherri hill dresses

Oakley Sunglasses Sale…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by Oakley Sunglasses Sale

Beats By Dre…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by Beats By Dre

black friday sales…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by black friday sales

cheap ralph lauren…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by cheap ralph lauren

MULBERRY BAGS…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by MULBERRY BAGS

MANCHESTER CITY JERSEY…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by MANCHESTER CITY JERSEY

bste…

louis vuitton automatic chronometer functions…

- Posted by bste

hone…

Las Vegas’ Most Luxurious Spots…

- Posted by hone

FLwYvmIT…

–…

- Posted by FLwYvmIT

YZqiYBWB…

–…

- Posted by YZqiYBWB

qlsPiMIP…

–…

- Posted by qlsPiMIP

Mbt Sale…

Prohibition policy in Gujarat — a tragic farce? | Journalist Profile | Reuters.com…

- Posted by Mbt Sale

hone…

louis vuitton everybody is so easygoing…

- Posted by hone

bste…

louis vuitton partly because i had my favourite designers around the corner and partly becuase i knew this would make be broke…

- Posted by bste